If you’ve been following along on my Instagram, you might have seen sneak peeks of a major project we’ve kept under wraps. It’s time for the official reveal: we replaced our old roof with designer shingles, and we couldn’t be happier with the result.
What began as a stressful surprise after Hurricane Helene ended up being a blessing in disguise.
Because our insurance covered most of the expense, we were able to upgrade the roof in a way that noticeably improved curb appeal and increased longevity. We did a lot of research and compiled everything we learned to help you if a roof replacement is on your to-do list.
Architectural Shingles vs Designer Shingles
Before the update, our roof had architectural shingles. Those are a step up from basic 3-tab shingles, offering more dimension and durability. Designer shingles, however, are a further upgrade and deliver a more refined, high-end appearance.
Architectural shingles provide a durable, dimensional look at a moderate price (roughly $5.50 to $12.25 per square foot). Designer shingles are thicker and more detailed, designed to mimic premium materials like slate or cedar shake, and typically cost more (about $12.50 to $15.50 per square foot).
Related: FAQs About Our Limewashed BrickHouse
Why We Chose Designer Roof Shingles
When we learned the roof needed replacement, we decided to treat it as an opportunity: if we were already dealing with the disruption, why not choose the option we truly wanted?
I didn’t know much about the differences at first, but as we looked into options, designer shingles stood out. They’re not your standard builder-grade 3-tab shingles. Designer shingles are engineered to recreate the look and texture of premium roofing materials like slate or cedar shake, adding depth and character to the exterior.
We selected CertainTeed Belmont luxury shingles in the Colonial Slate color. The result is a classic, timeless look with subtle tonal variation that elevates the whole house—details that become more apparent the more you look at it.
Related: Our Colonial Front Door Replacement
Related: 6 Ways to Add Instant Curb Appeal
What Makes Designer Shingles Different?
Here’s how designer shingles compare to more standard options:
Pros of Designer Shingles
- Enhanced curb appeal: Designer shingles replicate the look of upscale materials without the full cost of slate or wood.
- Improved durability: They are thicker and typically hold up better in high winds and severe weather—important for homeowners in hurricane-prone regions.
- Longer lifespan: Depending on the brand and installation, designer shingles can last 30 to 50 years or longer.
- More style options: These shingles come in a wide range of colors and textures to suit traditional, modern, or transitional homes.
Cons to Consider
- Higher upfront cost: Designer shingles are pricier than basic options, though insurance coverage can help offset the expense.
- Increased weight: Their thickness makes them heavier than standard shingles. Most roofs can support them, but it’s worth confirming with your roofer before choosing.
- Variability between brands: Quality and warranties differ, so research manufacturers and contractors carefully. We vetted many local companies and selected a roofing contractor we trusted—if you’re in the Charlotte area, we worked with Taylor Roofing, who recommended the CertainTeed Belmont shingles.
Related: Front Yard Makeover – How We Revived Our Lawn in a Year
Are Designer Shingles Worth It?
Short answer: yes.
Longer answer: they’re a smart investment if you want a roof that both performs and enhances your home’s exterior. Designer shingles can add resale value because buyers notice high-quality roofing. Even if you plan to stay in the house, the visual improvement is one you’ll enjoy every day.
There’s something satisfying about a roof that looks like slate without the maintenance and cost of real stone. It’s a detail that can make your home feel more cohesive—our new shingles complement the limewashed brick, shutters, front door, flower beds, and refreshed lawn in a way that ties the whole exterior together.
We still need to replace our old gutters, and copper gutters are on the wish list. That’s a future decision based on budget and priorities, but for now the roof feels like a completed chapter.
We’re thrilled with how the project turned out, and I hope this overview helps if you’re weighing your own roof replacement options.
More Curb Appeal Resources
- Our Colonial Front Door Makeover with Charleston Style Porch Decor
- Front Yard Makeover: How We Revived Our Lawn in a Year
- Best Flame Light Bulbs for a Gas Lantern Look
- How to Clean and Maintain Limewashed Brick
- 40 Best Faux Outdoor Plants
