A curated roundup of 14 commonly found thrift store treasures that work beautifully for fall decor or as year-round accents, plus practical ideas and simple DIY tips to create warm, cozy spaces.
I’ve been missing thrift store hunting lately, so I pulled together a list of the most useful secondhand finds that translate effortlessly into autumn styling. I prefer a subtle, layered approach to fall decorating—think warm colors, textured blankets, and a few natural stems—rather than a glut of pumpkins everywhere. Thrifted pieces are perfect for that relaxed, collected look and often cost a fraction of new items.
14 Best Fall Decor Items to Buy in Thrift Stores
1. Amber Glass
Amber glass jars and bottles add instant warmth and vintage charm. Use them as simple bud vases, group several sizes on a shelf, or convert shallow glass dishes into candles. Even recycled grocery jars can be given a second life with a little cleaning and styling.
2. Copper Mugs
Individual copper cups often appear mixed in with dinnerware. They don’t need to match; a mismatched collection makes an interesting table display and feels right at home with seasonal drinks like apple cider or spiced tea. A quick polish or light patina adds character.
3. Wreath
Secondhand wreaths can be found pre-assembled or as simple grapevine forms ready for a makeover. If you find a plain base, attach a few artificial stems, berries, or dried foliage to customize color and texture. A thrifted wreath is an economical foundation for seasonal updates.
4. Buckets and Planters
Secondhand planters and metal buckets are ideal for porch mums or indoor greenery. If the finish isn’t your style, spray paint is a fast fix—consider distressing for a farmhouse look or layering metallic paint for a richer feel. They’re great for grouping and creating varied height outdoors and in.
5. Picture Frames
Thrift stores are full of unique or inexpensive frames. Paint or refinish them to match your palette, then add seasonal printables or family photos. Framed art on shelves or mantels instantly elevates a vignette and gives a polished, layered look.
6. Wooden Bowls
Wooden salad bowls are plentiful and versatile. Fill them with mini pumpkins, pears, dried pods, or a mix of natural elements for a simple centerpiece. The warm tones of wood pair beautifully with fall hues and add organic texture to tabletops.
7. Blankets and Fabrics
Cozy throws and heavy fabrics can transform a room. Many thrifted blankets just need laundering, and fabric remnants can be turned into simple no-sew throws or pillow covers. Layer plaids and textured knits to create warmth and depth in seating areas.
8. Trays
Thrifted trays—wood, metal, or tiered—are practical for serving and styling. They help contain small groupings, keep coffee tables tidy, and are especially useful for buffet-style holiday meals. Mix sizes for layered tablescape designs.
9. Candle Holders
Candelabras, votive holders, and candlesticks add ambiance. Vintage or slightly weathered candle holders have charm; pair with beeswax or tapered candles for a moody fall vignette. Mix metals and heights for visual interest.
10. Wire Baskets and Bundt Pans
Wire baskets and vintage bundt pans can be repurposed as unique planters, wall decor, or seasonal craft bases. They lend a playful, slightly industrial touch—consider filling wire baskets with small gourds or using mini molds for crafted pumpkin ornaments.
11. Old Books
Stacked hardcover books add color, height, and texture on trays, side tables, or mantels. Look for covers in warm or muted tones that coordinate with your palette. Removing dust jackets often reveals attractive cloth-bound covers underneath.
12. Foam Pumpkins
Worn foam pumpkins are easy to update with paint techniques—try matte modern colors, metallic accents, or layered paint for a distressed effect. They’re lightweight, reusable, and ideal for crafting unique seasonal displays.
13. Metal Accents
Small metal pieces—figurines, trays, votives—add shine and contrast. A few coats of copper or brass spray paint can transform inexpensive finds into luxe-looking accents that feel festive and cohesive with autumnal colors.
14. Tablecloths and Fabrics
Tablecloths, scarves, or fabric yardage are useful for creating layered tabletops. Even a scarf or a few yards of woven fabric can act as a runner or backdrop for place settings, helping the table feel special for holiday dinners.
If you enjoy thrifted decorating, keep an eye out for these items when you shop—small updates like a fresh throw, a reclaimed tray, or a handful of amber bottles can make a big seasonal impact without being over the top.
For more thrift store decorating inspiration and DIY tutorials, check the blog for related posts and project ideas to adapt these finds to your personal style.
Save this post for later
