3 Techniques for DIY Painted Pumpkins: Spray Paint, Metallics, and Dirt for Concrete, Antique Brass, and Black Earthenware Finishes
I broke my usual fall-decorating rule for this one—because when you can transform inexpensive faux pumpkins with supplies you already have, why not get a little creative? I picked up three faux pumpkins at Target and used paint and simple materials from my stash to create three distinct, modern finishes: antique brass, concrete, and black earthenware.
These three easy DIY painted pumpkin techniques work on any faux pumpkin, vase, or small decor object. They’re budget-friendly and give a high-end, textured look without the cost or fragility of the real materials.
3 Modern Paint Techniques for Fake Pumpkins
Antique Brass Pumpkin
Supplies used (simple, common items):
- Spray primer (optional, for extra adhesion)
- Gold metallic spray paint
- Antique gold Rub ‘n Buff or a similar metallic wax finish
Steps
1. Prime the pumpkin with a light coat of spray primer and let it dry. Primer helps spray paint adhere better and gives a uniform base.
2. Spray the primed pumpkin with a metallic gold spray paint. Apply thin even coats to avoid runs and allow each coat to dry fully.
3. Once the spray paint is dry, use an old craft brush or fingertip to apply a small amount of antique gold Rub ‘n Buff. Work it into grooves and lightly rub off excess with a paper towel to reveal highlights and a naturally aged patina.
This technique creates an elegant antique brass finish that looks upscale but is durable enough for everyday display—even around kids and pets.
Concrete Pumpkin
Supplies used:
- Concrete hobby paint or a mix of light and medium gray craft paints
- Optional: a small amount of fine sand to add texture
- A chip brush or stiff bristle brush
Steps
1. Paint the entire pumpkin with a base coat of light gray. Use even strokes and cover the surface completely.
2. While the light gray is still slightly wet, dab on the medium gray with a stippling motion to create natural-looking concrete splotches and variations. If you want more texture, mix a tiny bit of fine sand into the darker gray before applying.
Allow the paint to dry completely. The end result resembles a small concrete sculpture, perfect for neutral or minimalist fall decor.
Black Earthenware Pumpkin
Supplies used:
- Spray primer (optional for durability)
- Flat black spray paint
- A cup of garden dirt mixed with 2–3 tablespoons of water to make thick mud
- Paper towels for wiping
Steps
1. Prime the pumpkin lightly and let dry.
2. Spray the pumpkin with flat black spray paint, applying thin, even coats and letting each layer dry.
3. Spread a layer of the dirt-and-water mix over the pumpkin and let it dry several hours or overnight. The dried mud gives a raw, natural texture similar to earthenware pottery.
4. Gently rub off parts of the dried mud with a paper towel to reveal the black underneath. Adjust how much you remove to achieve the desired level of earthiness.
This rustic earthenware look is trending on vases and lamp bases and adds an organic, layered feel to fall arrangements. You can tone down the dirt if you prefer a subtler result.
Which Finish Should You Try?
Each finish brings a different mood: antique brass for a polished, vintage look; concrete for minimalist or industrial decor; and black earthenware for an organic, moody vibe. All three techniques are quick, affordable, and adaptable to other decor pieces like vases, small sculptures, or thrifted finds.
If you plan to use painted pumpkins in high-traffic areas or around children, consider sealing delicate finishes with a clear protective spray for extra durability.
Which of these modern painted pumpkin techniques is your favorite? I’m leaning toward the antique brass, but the black earthenware has a lot of character. These finishes are flexible, inexpensive, and perfect for updating small accents across your home this season.
